MPE 1 Mei 2013

Seeing the state like a migrant: why so manu non-criminals break immigration laws (David Kyle & Christina A. Siracusa) --> 2001 “illicit flows and criminal things”

James Scott --> state --> mismanage the social reality --> creating them for ‘illegal aliens’ --> profitable ambiguities

cases: migrant smuggler/trafficker, organized crime, transnational crimes

Mexico: see the illegal migration as a normalized activities

migrant – exporting schemes:

1. understand the political and moral reasoning why so many non-criminals are choosing to selectively disregard some state immigration laws prohibiting unauthorized entry and work

mengapa non kriminal menganggap itu adalah hal yang normal

2. embedded in historical social relationship involving both private and public actors

3. bluring the definition of legal and illegal

4. migrants are driven by social mobility, pre-existing corruption, uneven development

5. commodified labour as the consequence of politically weak state

missing points:

1. legal activities: TKW exporting is legal

2. moral reasoning: always ended with abuse of power

3. driven and consequence: social mobility and politically weak state?

catatan kelompok dan Bu Endang

baca literatur untuk tahu budaya

3 hari --> topik dan informan. abis itu mesti fixed

minggu depan review bacaan

latar belakang, masalah, pertanyaan penelitian (bagaimana, apakah?), kerangka konsep, metode penelitian (cara meneliti, sifat penelitian)